Tally-Ho and I (the Bad Man) attended a local wine merchant’s Top-Flight Cabernet Sauvignon tasting the other night. It was BLIND, but you only got the typical 2 ounce pour, and it was difficult (though I of course was able to pull it off) go back and re-taste, so it wasn’t exactly an ideally thorough tasting but I was on fire so I think my results are fairly sound (kids at home: that sentence will make your English teacher look scornfully down their nose over their horn-rimmed bifocals in your general direction, so please don’t imitate its structure - I’m a paid professional). (Well, not exactly paid). (And not exactly professional).
Here are the wines and my tasting notes in italics:
$65 to $100 Flight
Bag #1, Silver Oak Napa Valley 2004 $100.00
Redwood tree, cherry and mint, acid, dry, austere. BM: 83
Bag #2, Grgich Hills Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 $65.00 92 WS
Egg white, dark black fruit, high acid, lush mouthfeel, fine tannins. BM: 90
Bag #3, Kenwood Artist Series 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon $75.00 93 WS
Dark herbal, good acid, nice spicy finish. BM: 85
Bag #4, Oberon 2005 Hillside Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon by Rob Mondavi Jr. $75.00 91 WS
Prune, chocolate, great length, integrated tannins, rich spicy finish. BM: 85
Bag #5, Nickel & Nickel Sullenger Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 $95.00 96 WE
Violets, oak, gritty tannins - satisfying! BM: 90
Bag #6, David Arthur 2006 Napa Cabernet Sauvignon $95.00 96 WE
Baked yeast, great length, finish, smacky mouthfeel, a little late-havesty. BM: 90
My top 3 favourites were:
1st: Nickel & Nickel Sullenger Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 $95.00 BM: 90
2nd: David Arthur 2006 Napa Cabernet Sauvignon $95.00 BM: 90
3rd: Grgich Hills Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 $65.00 BM: 90
I’m a little disappointed that I found the Grgich so good - I have always been very unimpressed with Mike’s wines. Silver Oak, as I have always maintained, is one of the most consistently over-hyped and over-rated Napa wines. Kinda like Opus One.
$100 to $200 Flight
Bag #1, Far Niente 2006 Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon $150.00
Rough tannins, edgy, cherry. BM: 85
Bag #2, Dominus Estate 2006 Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon $130.00 96 RP
Sour soap nose, chalky tannins, great finish. BM: 85
Bag #3, Hartwell Stags Leap District Reserve 2005 $169.99 95 WS
Pungent perfume - very Bordeaux nose, good finish, something strange cuts down the middle of the palate. BM: 92
Bag #4, Ghost Block 2006 Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon $100.00
Green pepper, egg salad sandwich, floral, a little hollow, thin, followed by chocolate - needs time to come together. BM: 87
Bag #5, Caymus Special Selection Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 $170.00 94 WS
From the wine merchant: “There have only been 11 California Cabernet Sauvignon’s scored 98 points or higher by the Wine Spectator. Caymus Special Selection has been scored that high an amazing 7 times. It has been rated 94 to 97pts 11 times, 98pts 5 times and 99 points 2 times. Not even Screaming Eagle, Shafer Hillside, Phelps Insignia, or any other Napa “Cult” Cab’s which sell for twice the price or more can claim this.”
Briary, Cookies & Crème! Lush mouthfeel, great extract, tannic finish. BM: 95
Bag #6, Joseph Phelps 2005 Insignia $200.00 95 RP, 92 WS, 97 “Wine of the Year” The Wine News
California herbaceous (ugh!), forward fruit, very New World. BM: 80
Bag #7, Continuum 2006 by Tim Mondavi $169.99 95 WS
Vanilla cinnamon, slight bitter notes on the finish, very balanced, tannins in the front. BM: 94
My top 3 favourites were:
1st: Caymus Special Selection Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 $170.00 BM: 95
2nd: Continuum 2006 by Tim Mondavi $169.99 BM: 94
3rd: Hartwell Stags Leap District Reserve 2005 $169.99 BM: 92
I wasn’t exactly blown away given the price point, and it didn’t seem like we were robbing the cradle (as it should drinking $100-$200/bottle on release). I am pleased with my overall choice of Caymus Special Select as that has been one of my favourite cabs since I started drinking it in the 80s. Likewise I’m very disappointed with the Phelps Insignia because that is a wine I have loved big-time since the 80s. But high marks are in order for that Continuum; Tim has turned in a wonderful effort to continue the Mondavi legacy into the new century.

